| Year Awarded | Recipients | Class Year |
| 1991 | Myrtle L. Graves | 1937 |
| | Estelle M. Halloran | 1940 |
| | Marie Collins | 1948SJ |
| | Genevieve Quilty Chase | 1936 |
| | Margaret Boylan Kelley | 1938 |
| | Elizabeth Cavan Johnston | 1936 |
| | Sister Mary Luke Tercek | 1938SJ |
| | Jeanne Mary Burrige | 1962SJ |
| | Ethel Doran Dindia | 1933 |
| | Johanna M. Gardner | 1953 |
| | Margaret Lynch MacGillis | 1944 |
| 1992 | Carol Miceli Lograsso | 1958 |
| | Mary Rose Sennett Murphy | 1942 |
| 1993 | Adelaide Elizabeth Gallagher | 1929 |
| | Ursula Mary Gallagher | 1929 |
| 1994 | Mary Perciak Herrick | 1966 |
| | Carol Cerney O'Connell | 1955 |
| 1995 | Peg Murtagh Durkin | 1961 |
| 1996 | Sister Rosemary Hocevar, OSU | 1960 |
| 1997 | Joan Rosskopf Harkulich | 1953SJ |
| 1998 | Nora Burke Beach | 1978 |
| 1999 | No honoree | |
| 2000 | Jeanne Hennessey Casey | 1983 |
| 2001 | Marie Lavelle LoPresti | 1942 |
| | Agnes Sperie Maynard | 1960 |
| 2002 | Stella Ann Grove | 1982 |
| | Kay Brown Malec | 1957SJ |
| 2003 | Carol Jean Gilles | 1953 |
| | Sister Genevieve Jankowski | 1945 |
| 2004 | Mary Jeanne Airnault Hable | 1943 |
| | Ann Moley Monastra | 1956SJ |
| | Margaret Reddy O'Neill | 1944 |
| 2005 | Frances Ryan Comiskey | 1961 |
| | Patricia Duggan | 1960SJ |
| 2006 | Mary Bernhardy Schloss | 1943 |
| 2007 | Katherine "Kappy" Pope Melari | 1965 |
| 2008 | Rosalind DeYampert Bettis | 1995 |
