| Year Awarded | Recipients | Class Year |
| 1971 | Dora B. Somerville | 1939 |
| 1972 | Carol Cerney O'Connell | 1955 |
| 1973 | Dorothy Duffin Ferrara | 1935 |
| 1974 | Carol Anne Lanphier | 1946 |
| 1975 | Mercedes Hurley McManus | 1926 |
| 1976 | Myrtle L. Graves | 1937 |
| 1977 | Mary Rose Oakar | 1962 |
| 1978 | Beatrice Vincent | 1934 |
| 1979 | Sister Rose Angela Johnson, OSU | 1946 |
| | Patricia Winstead-Fry | 1965SJ |
| 1980 | Patricia Arth LaFlamme | 1949 |
| 1981 | Sister Mary Kenan Dulzer, OSU | 1954SJ |
| 1982 | Mary Rose Sennett Murphy | 1942 |
| | Anita Mullen McEvoy | 1943 |
| 1983 | Nancy Lee Graf | 1958 |
| 1984 | Lois Hummer Hopkins | 1946 |
| | Diane O'Neill McGivern | 1961SJ |
| 1985 | Dorothy Marie Muhitsch | 1946 |
| | Mary Jo Potts Moran | 1951 |
| 1986 | Mary T. Gavin | 1936 |
| | Doris Gibson Simonis | 1952 |
| 1987 | Mary Edna Singleton Lenaghan | 1945SJ |
| | Mardee Dempsey Fayen | 1945 |
| 1988 | Ann Laughlin Marotta | 1953 |
| 1989 | Sister Michael Francis Hearon, OSU | 1933 |
| 1990 | Margaret Reddy O'Neill | 1944 |
| | Maryhelen Cole Kreidler | 1961SJ |
| 1991 | Rae Cecilia Kelly Kipp | 1936 |
| 1992 | Carmella Consiglio Frantz | 1949 |
| 1993 | Sister Anna Margaret Gilbride, OSU | 1956SJ |
| | Denise San Antonio Zeman | 1974 |
| 1994 | Johanna M. Gardner | 1953 |
| | Margaret Lynch MacGillis | 1944 |
| 1995 | Ethel Doran Dindia | 1933 |
| | Janis Mohr O'Reilly Gold | 1988 |
| 1996 | Sister M. Kilian Hufgard, OSU | |
| | Sister Anne Marie Diederich, OSU | 1966 |
| 1997 | Kathleen Dailey | 1967 |
| | Susan McKeown Mueller | 1961SJ |
| 1998 | Mary Jeanne Airnault Hable | 1943 |
| 1999 | The Ursuline Sisters of Cleveland | |
| 2000-1 | Diane Davis Lardie | 1959 |
| 2002 | Sister Beverly Anne LoGrasso, OSU | 1970 |
| | Barbara Gibson Gustafson | 1955SJ |
| 2003 | Alice Kelly Monroe | 1943 |
| | Joan Payne Riess | 1955SJ |
| 2004 | Renee Jones Weeks | 1970 |
| 2005 | Sister Virginia DeVinne, OSU | 1972 |
| | Christine Doman Wynd | 1974SJ |
| 2006 | Alice Bender Ferfolia | 1984 |
| 2007 | Christine Kesslem Carroll | 1972 |
| 2008 | Sister Mary Eugene Gear, OSU | 1953SJ |
